Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Fish Creek

Pizza restaurant · Gibraltar

1

@eater

"Wisconsin isn’t especially well-known for its pizza, but Wild Tomato owner Britton Unkefer (Wolfgang Puck’s Postrio, Water Street Brewery) has defied expectations and successfully leveraged industry knowledge to bring lovely wood-fired pies to Fish Creek and Sister Bay. He also makes liberal use of ingredients from the area’s many small farms on pizzas like the Fun Guy (five types of mushrooms, spinach, caramelized onions). Unkefer also owns Clover & Zot pub in Baileys Harbor." - Naomi Waxman

Door County, Wisconsin’s best restaurants - Eater Chicago

4023 WI-42, Fish Creek, WI 54212 Get directions

wildtomatopizza.com
@wildtomatofishcreek

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

White Gull Inn

Inn · Gibraltar

Charming rooms & cottages in a quaint Victorian B&B with a casual restaurant & live folk music. This classic B&B in Fish Creek occupies a Victorian house, 2 annexes and cottages, and lies a 5-minute walk from Sunset Beach Park and 0.7 miles from Peninsula State Park. Decorated in country-style furnishings, the homey rooms feature free WiFi, TVs and DVD players, air-conditioning and private bathrooms; some have electric fireplaces and/or whirlpool tubs. The 1- and 2-bedroom cottages add porches. Accommodations for 4 to 8 people in nearby houses are also available. Breakfast at the cozy restaurant is free, and open to the public; it also offers lunch, dinner, seasonal outdoor fish boils (a regional specialty) and live folk music events.

3 Postcards

Fish Creek Scenic Boat Tours

Boat tour agency · Gibraltar

Experience stunning views of the Strawberry Islands on a partly covered tour boat, where live music and knowledgeable guides elevate your scenic cruise.

1 Postcard

Alexander's of Door County

Steak house · Gibraltar

An upscale yet cozy Wisconsin supper club, this charming spot serves mouthwatering steaks and seafood alongside cocktails, making it a local favorite.

1 Postcard

Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard

Dessert shop · Gibraltar

Frozen custard, tasty sandwiches, beautiful location

1 Postcard

Pelletier's Restaurant & Fish Boil

Seafood restaurant · Gibraltar

Pelletier's is a seasonal gem where you can savor a classic American breakfast, then settle in for an unforgettable outdoor fish boil against a beautiful backdrop.

1 Postcard

Hyline Orchard Farm Market Inc., Door County

Farmers' market · Gibraltar

This charming family-owned orchard in Door County offers pick-your-own cherries, plums, and a delightful farmers' market packed with fresh local goodies.

1 Postcard

County Clare Irish Inn & Pub

Irish restaurant · Vankee Hill

Nestled near the lakefront, this cozy Irish-inspired hotel boasts charming rooms with whirlpool tubs and a lively pub featuring hearty pub fare and live music.

1 Postcard

The Diplomat

Restaurant · Brady Street

The Diplomat in Milwaukee offers a delightful twist on American classics with a cool retro vibe, inventive cocktails, and consistently stellar service.

7 Postcards

Lupi & Iris

Fine dining restaurant · Juneau Town

Lupi & Iris is a chic spot in Downtown Milwaukee serving exquisite French and Italian dishes, perfect for brunch, dinner, or a celebratory cocktail.

5 Postcards

Grampa's Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant · Marquette

Nestled on trendy Williamson St., this cozy spot serves up gourmet thin-crust pizza, craft beers, and delightful desserts, all in a charming atmosphere.

1 Postcard