Bagel Supreme

Bagel shop · Fort Hamilton

1

@eater

"This Bay Ridge bakery offers a bagel so big and bulbous, that the holes have nearly disappeared — one is almost enough to be shared by two. The shop furnishes views of the nearby Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge, and there’s a park across the street where you can eat your purchases in fine weather. (It also sells subs on rolls baked on the premises.) Its most unusual product is the French toast bagel, which is sweet, sticky, and covered in powdered sugar." - Robert Sietsema, Eater Staff

The Best Bagels in New York City
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

9401 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209 Get directions

bagelsupreme.com

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

El Pingüino

Bar · Greenpoint

This cozy cocktail bar is the perfect spot for a seafood feast and expertly crafted drinks, all served by friendly staff in a charming atmosphere.

15 Postcards

Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels

Bagel shop · South Slope

At Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels in Park Slope, dive into a bagel haven featuring chewy classics and inventive sandwiches, perfect for any time of day.

11 Postcards

Supermoon Bakehouse

Bakery · Lower East Side

Supermoon Bakehouse is the go-to Lower East Side bakery for mind-blowing cruffins, over-the-top pastries, and seasonal doughnuts that are a must-try.

10 Postcards

Brooklyn Steel

Live music venue · Williamsburg

Nestled in Brooklyn's industrial heart, Brooklyn Steel is a spacious gem with stellar acoustics, a sleek vibe, and a lineup that draws music lovers near and far.

0 Postcards

El Born

Tapas restaurant · Greenpoint

El Born is a cozy Greenpoint tapas bar blending Barcelona-style small plates, inventive cocktails, and a chic exposed-brick vibe perfect for relaxed gatherings.

6 Postcards

Caracas To Go

Venezuelan restaurant · Lower East Side

Caracas in Manhattan exclusively offers delivery and takeout of vibrant Venezuelan street food, including the must-try arepas and fresh salads.

3 Postcards

Atelier December

Cafe · Flatbush

Atelier December is the new neighborhood gem with a vibrant atmosphere, friendly service, and a menu packed with delicious, halal options.

2 Postcards

Elea

Greek restaurant · Upper West Side

This Upper West Side gem radiates Greek Island charm with its warm ambiance and seafood-centric menu, perfect for a memorable meal or date night.

14 Postcards

53 Broadway

Mexican restaurant · Williamsburg

Casual Mexican eatery offering tacos & tortillas in an industrial-style space that has a terrace.

5 Postcards

Bluehour

Film production company · Williamsburg

Bluehour is a trendsetting creative production company in Brooklyn that excels at unique content, also offering inventive late-night eats from a gas station stand.

2 Postcards