"This old-timer was founded in 1916 in the Coney Island subway station, but moved to Staten Island in 2001. Much of the candy is era appropriate: When you the last time you stumbled into a candy store where the specialties included caramel apples, salt water taffy, marshmallow pops, and fudge? Pink candied popcorn and chocolate-dipped grapes are some of the more unique products." - Robert Sietsema