Pete & Elda's Bar / Carmen's Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant · Neptune City

5

@eater

The Best Dishes Eater Editors Ate This Week, November 2023 | Eater NY

"A childhood pizzeria in Neptune that’s been open since 1961, I remembered it as a dive-bar atmosphere where giant pizzas come with super-thin, Saltine-white crusts and only a whisper of sauce and toppings — the kind of old-school place so iconic it’ll even offer a kooky limited-edition free t-shirt if you finish a whole pie yourself." - Eater Staff

https://ny.eater.com/2023/11/6/23943759/nyc-best-dishes-eater-november-2023

96 Woodland Ave, Neptune City, NJ 07753 Get directions

peteandeldas.com
@pete_eldas

5 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

Palmer's Quality Meats

Butcher shop · Neptune City

Old-school butcher shop with pasture-raised meats & sandwiches

2 Postcards

Mack's Pizza of Stone Harbor

Pizza restaurant · Stone Harbor

Specialty pizzas with thin, crispy crusts and savory toppings

5 Postcards

Garden State Diner

Diner · Newark

Old-fashioned diner burgers, shakes, cocktails, baked goods

1 Postcard

Jenkinson's Boardwalk

Amusement park · Point Pleasant Beach

Family-friendly boardwalk with rides, arcade, mini-golf, aquarium

2 Postcards

Pork Roll Store

Butcher shop · Upper Freehold

Specializing in pork roll, sausages, steaks, and bacon

1 Postcard

Frank's Deli & Restaurant

Deli · Asbury Park

Classic NJ luncheonette with pork roll sandwiches & shakes

15 Postcards

Cafe 2825

Italian restaurant · Atlantic City

Tableside mozzarella & pasta in cheese wheel, intimate space

3 Postcards

DreamWorks Water Park

Water park · East Rutherford

Wave pool, waterslides, lazy river, movie-themed rides for kids

1 Postcard

The Crab Trap

Seafood restaurant · Somers Point

Seafood-focused menu with outdoor bar & deck offering harbor views

3 Postcards

Brickwall Tavern & Dining Room

Restaurant · Asbury Park

Creative dishes, craft brews, live music, and a trendy vibe

1 Postcard