Papa's Tomato Pies shared by @grubstreet on Postcard

2

Papa's Tomato Pies

Pizza restaurant · Robbinsville ·

13,564 Postcards · 1,476 Cities

The Best Places to Eat and Drink in NYC This Summer

"A historic Trenton-area pizzeria (in operation since 1912) famous for the regional “mustard pie”: a thin-crust tomato pie with spicy brown mustard spread under the toppings that yields a greasy, well-turned, slightly charred slice with loyal devotees willing to drive across the Turnpike." - Alan Sytsma, Beth Sacca

https://www.grubstreet.com/article/best-restaurants-nyc-nj-2023.html

Information

Historic pizzeria known for its Trenton-style tomato pie

mustard pie

tomato pie

thin crust

crispy crust

great pizza

friendly service

old school

sauce

Featured in Grub Street

19 Main St, Robbinsville Twp, NJ 08691 Get directions

$10–20

Restroom

Accepts reservations

Popular for lunch

Popular for dinner

Cozy

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

See full details

2

Information

Historic pizzeria known for its Trenton-style tomato pie

mustard pie

tomato pie

thin crust

crispy crust

great pizza

friendly service

old school

sauce

Featured in Grub Street

19 Main St, Robbinsville Twp, NJ 08691 Get directions

$10–20

Restroom

Accepts reservations

Popular for lunch

Popular for dinner

Cozy

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

Papa's Tomato Pies by null

See full details

More Places For You

Photo of De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies

De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies

Italian restaurant · Robbinsville

Legendary BYOB for create-your-own tomato pies since 1947

2 Postcards

Photo of Cameo

Cameo

Gift shop · Atlantic City

Unique gifts and cutting-edge gadgets for memorable occasions

1 Postcard

Photo of Jono Pandolfi Designs, Inc.

Jono Pandolfi Designs, Inc.

Pottery manufacturer · Union City

Restaurant-quality ceramics, handcrafted tableware, elevated dining experiences

8 Postcards

Photo of Knife and Fork Inn

Knife and Fork Inn

Steak house · Atlantic City

Upscale eatery featuring steaks, chops & seafood, wine

4 Postcards

Photo of The Surfing Pig

The Surfing Pig

Barbecue restaurant · North Wildwood

BBQ, burgers, seafood & cocktails with water views

4 Postcards

Photo of Tamborim Bar & Grill

Tamborim Bar & Grill

Brazilian restaurant · Jersey City

Authentic Brazilian cuisine, caipirinhas, picanha, and pao de queijo

3 Postcards

Photo of Charrito's

Charrito's

Mexican restaurant · Hudson County

Mexican plates & tableside guacamole with NYC views

1 Postcard

Photo of Bread & Salt

Bread & Salt

Bakery · Jersey City

Artisan Italian breads, Roman pizza, pastries & sandwiches

41 Postcards

Photo of Portugalia Bar & Restaurant

Portugalia Bar & Restaurant

Portuguese restaurant · Newark

Authentic Portuguese fare, large portions, convivial bar and dining room

2 Postcards

Photo of 87 Sussex

87 Sussex

Restaurant · Jersey City

Creative American fare, wine, cocktails, and warm, attentive service

1 Postcard