2

Papa's Tomato Pies

Pizza restaurant · Robbinsville ·

Papa's Tomato Pies

Pizza restaurant · Robbinsville ·
@grubstreet
13,564 Postcards · 1,477 Cities

The Best Places to Eat and Drink in NYC This Summer

"A historic Trenton-area pizzeria (in operation since 1912) famous for the regional “mustard pie”: a thin-crust tomato pie with spicy brown mustard spread under the toppings that yields a greasy, well-turned, slightly charred slice with loyal devotees willing to drive across the Turnpike." - Alan Sytsma, Beth Sacca

https://www.grubstreet.com/article/best-restaurants-nyc-nj-2023.html

Information

Historic pizzeria serving famous thin-crust mustard pie

mustard pie
tomato pie
thin crust
crispy crust
great sauce
friendly service
old school
pizza
Google Rating
4.6 (1.8K)
Yelp Rating
4.0
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in

19 Main St, Robbinsville Twp, NJ 08691 Get directions

$10–20

Order delivery
See Menu
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Cozy
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
See full details

2

Information

Historic pizzeria serving famous thin-crust mustard pie

mustard pie
tomato pie
thin crust
crispy crust
great sauce
friendly service
old school
pizza
Google Rating
4.6 (1.8K)
Yelp Rating
4.0
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in

19 Main St, Robbinsville Twp, NJ 08691 Get directions

$10–20

Order delivery
See Menu
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Cozy
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
Papa's Tomato Pies by null
See full details

More Places For You

De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies

Italian restaurant · Robbinsville

Legendary BYOB for create-your-own tomato pies since 1947

2 Postcards

Mule Barn Tavern Restaurant - Highlands

American restaurant · Middletown

American classics, craft beers & cocktails with waterfront views

3 Postcards

Philippine Bread House

Bakery · Jersey City

Traditional Filipino bakery with ube cakes, ensaymadas, & hot lunch

7 Postcards

Lita

Restaurant · Strathmore

Modern Iberian cuisine from Top Chef alum David Viana

9 Postcards

Shake Shack Union

Hamburger restaurant · Union County

Gourmet fast-food chain serving burgers, fries, and frozen custard

1 Postcard

COMPTON’S

Sandwich shop · Cliffside Park

Sandwiches, breakfast burritos, chopped cheese, games

3 Postcards

Circle Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Avalon

Thin crust pizza, cheesesteaks, and salads with outdoor seating

2 Postcards

Big Daddy's Dogs

Hot dog restaurant · Passaic County

Creative hot dogs with unique toppings and a huge hot sauce collection

1 Postcard

Summit Diner

Diner · Summit

Classic diner fare: Taylor ham, egg & cheese, pancakes

4 Postcards

Bread & Salt

Bakery · Jersey City

Roman-style pizza, exceptional breads, Italian deli fare

41 Postcards