"On Wednesdays, Anthony's Paninoteca makes pastrami. On Thursdays, porchetta. And on Tuesdays, the special is The KiKi—a bread-based behemoth involving lemony layers of chicken francese and mozzarella on butter-soaked garlic bread. There’s always the roast beef. In other words there’s no bad day to come to this Great Kills shop with chandeliers on the ceiling. Though young compared to some of the other places on this list, Anthony's is an instant classic." - willa moore, will hartman, bryan kim, molly fitzpatrick