"Open since 1921, McNally’s Tavern in Chestnut Hill has long served classic sandwiches, cocktails, and beers in massive, Viking-like mugs to people in the neighborhood. Speaking of classics, nothing’s more iconic than our favorite, “The Schmitter” sandwich. The massive cheesesteak-like combination, with beef, fried onions, and cheese, is topped with grilled salami and a housemade Thousand Island-style special sauce. " - candis mclean, alison kessler