"In a year of so much seafood, it’s fitting that one of the most pared-back dishes—a platter where each oyster shone and each shrimp sparkled atop pebbles of ice—was also one of the best. Simply put, Penny’s Ice Box is the most quietly luxurious experience $39 can buy. Two more expensive versions include a greater variety and quantity of uber-fresh seafood." - bryan kim, molly fitzpatrick, willa moore, will hartman, sonal shah