"The frozen piña colada at Connolly’s gets all the credit, but you can get one at Rockaway Tiki Bar to-go, which will make your sticky walk to the beach considerably nicer. It’s also a great post-beach move, because you can snag a seat at the bar and cool off with a mai tai next to someone who doesn’t care that you’re covered in sand. There’s a menu of tiki drinks, and hanging lights in the shape of pufferfish, plus a robust sushi section of the menu. Or if you’re anti-fish, how about a Hawaiian slider?" - willa moore, molly fitzpatrick, neha talreja