"Bayville, Long Island; 70 minutes from Midtown No haunted house will be able to compete with the nightmare of a G train shutdown. But if you’re looking for a close second on Long Island, you can try Bayville Scream Park. This place is six different haunted attractions in one, plus they offer zombie axe-throwing, which sounds both terrifying and therapeutic." - neha talreja, hannah albertine, carina finn koeppicus, molly fitzpatrick