"If you're feeling bummed about the number of candles on your proverbial cake, plan a splashy, mutton-centric celebration at this Midtown steakhouse, which opened in 1885, and where the air is as thick with history as it once was with pipe smoke. Get yourself their mutton chop or porterhouse, and take a photo with the sugar packet, which happily reminds you, "I AM 139 YEARS OLD." - will hartman, bryan kim, neha talreja, sonal shah, molly fitzpatrick, willa moore