New Bethel Ordinary shared by @postcardnews on Postcard

1

New Bethel Ordinary

Pizza restaurant · Wanamaker ·

22,027 Postcards · 1,950 Cities

Franklin Township favorite with party-cut, topping-loaded pies that feed a crowd and fuel lively local debates about Indy-style pizza. Frequently mentioned by local outlets and beloved by southside families for value, nostalgia, and sheer heft.

https://indytoday.6amcity.com/city-guide/live/best-pizza-indianapolis-in

Best Pizza in Indianapolis (2025)

View this post on Instagram

Information

Loaded pizzas with tons of toppings, great wings and burgers

loaded pizza

great pizza

friendly service

attentive servers

great service

full bar

beer selection

meat lovers pizza

8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239 Get directions

$10–20

Restroom

Accepts reservations

Popular for lunch

Popular for dinner

Cozy

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

See full details

1

Information

Loaded pizzas with tons of toppings, great wings and burgers

loaded pizza

great pizza

friendly service

attentive servers

great service

full bar

beer selection

meat lovers pizza

8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239 Get directions

$10–20

Restroom

Accepts reservations

Popular for lunch

Popular for dinner

Cozy

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

New Bethel Ordinary by null

See full details

More Places For You

Photo of Taylor's Bakery

Taylor's Bakery

Bakery · Millersville

Custom cakes, pastries, ice cream, and dog treats from 1913

1 Postcard

Photo of Crate & Barrel

Crate & Barrel

Furniture store · Keystone At the Crossing

Stylish furniture, kitchenware, home essentials & design services

2 Postcards

Photo of Beholder

Beholder

Fine dining restaurant · Woodruff Place

Creative dishes and cocktails featuring local produce

5 Postcards

Photo of Bake Sale Indy

Bake Sale Indy

Bakery · Mayflower Meadows

Artisanal bakery offering fresh baguettes, croissants, and sourdough

1 Postcard

Photo of BEAST

BEAST

Hamburger restaurant · Riverside

Burgers, chili cheese fries, and amazing Brussel sprouts

3 Postcards

Photo of The Quarter

The Quarter

Bar · Wellington

NOLA-inspired eatery with live music, seafood & cocktails

1 Postcard

Photo of Smash'd Midwest Burgers Irvington

Smash'd Midwest Burgers Irvington

Hamburger restaurant · Irvington

Casual eatery with indoor-outdoor seating for classic burgers

1 Postcard

Photo of Lil Dumplings Noodle Bar

Lil Dumplings Noodle Bar

Noodle shop · Indianapolis

Dan Dan noodles, dumplings, and bao in a lively food hall

2 Postcards

Photo of Fat Dan's Deli

Fat Dan's Deli

American restaurant · Mass Ave Arts District

Smoked meats, burgers, loaded tots & craft beer

1 Postcard

Photo of Root & Bone - Indianapolis

Root & Bone - Indianapolis

Southern restaurant (US) · Mozel Sander Projects

Southern comfort food with creative cocktails and a chic vibe

8 Postcards