1

New Bethel Ordinary

Pizza restaurant · Wanamaker ·

New Bethel Ordinary

Pizza restaurant · Wanamaker ·
@postcardnews
22,027 Postcards · 1,950 Cities

Franklin Township favorite with party-cut, topping-loaded pies that feed a crowd and fuel lively local debates about Indy-style pizza. Frequently mentioned by local outlets and beloved by southside families for value, nostalgia, and sheer heft.

https://indytoday.6amcity.com/city-guide/live/best-pizza-indianapolis-in
Best Pizza in Indianapolis (2025)
View this post on Instagram

Information

Loaded pizzas with tons of toppings, great wings and burgers

loaded pizza
great service
friendly staff
meat lovers pizza
great food
pizza crust
tenderloin sandwich
full bar
Google Rating
4.5 (2.6K)
Yelp Rating
3.9
Placeholder

8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239 Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Cozy
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
See full details

1

Information

Loaded pizzas with tons of toppings, great wings and burgers

loaded pizza
great service
friendly staff
meat lovers pizza
great food
pizza crust
tenderloin sandwich
full bar
Google Rating
4.5 (2.6K)
Yelp Rating
3.9
Placeholder

8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239 Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Cozy
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
See full details

More Places For You

Bottleworks Hotel

Hotel · Indianapolis

Art Deco hotel in former Coca-Cola plant with chic rooms

4 Postcards

Meridian Restaurant & Bar

New American restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects

New American comfort food in a rustic-chic space with patio

1 Postcard

Garden Table

Restaurant · Mass. Ave Arts District

Fresh juices, inventive New American fare, botanical setting

4 Postcards

PB&J Factory

Sandwich shop · Downtown

Gourmet PB&J sandwiches, creative flavors, build your own options

1 Postcard

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant · Vertland

Family-style Italian eatery with kitschy decor & large portions

1 Postcard

Vito Provolone's

Italian restaurant · Lindenwood

Hearty Italian fare, famous for vodka sauce & garlic bread

2 Postcards

Eiteljorg Museum of American Indians and Western Art

Art museum · Canal Walk

American West art, Native artists, modern materials, hands-on play

0 Postcards

Bluebeard

Fine dining restaurant · Fletcher Place

New American kitchen serving sharing plates & craft cocktails

7 Postcards

Fat Dan's Deli

Deli · Mozel Sander Projects

Smoked wings, burgers, Chicago dogs, Italian beef, fries

2 Postcards

Nesso

Restaurant · Indianapolis

Italian seafood, local meats, fresh pasta & extensive wine list

1 Postcard