1

New Bethel Ordinary

Pizza restaurant · Wanamaker ·

New Bethel Ordinary

Pizza restaurant · Wanamaker ·
@postcardnews
20,018 Postcards · 1,279 Cities

Franklin Township favorite with party-cut, topping-loaded pies that feed a crowd and fuel lively local debates about Indy-style pizza. Frequently mentioned by local outlets and beloved by southside families for value, nostalgia, and sheer heft.

https://indytoday.6amcity.com/city-guide/live/best-pizza-indianapolis-in
Best Pizza in Indianapolis (2025)
View this post on Instagram

Information

Generous toppings on pizza, salads, burgers, plus patio seating

Placeholder
Placeholder

8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239, USA Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
See full details

1

Information

Generous toppings on pizza, salads, burgers, plus patio seating

Placeholder
Placeholder

8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239, USA Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
New Bethel Ordinary by null
See full details

More Places For You

Commissary Barber & Barista

Coffee shop · Mass Ave Arts District

Cafe with expertly crafted drinks & modern barber shop

1 Postcard

The Children's Museum of Indianapolis

Children's museum · Crown Hill

World's largest children's museum with 5 floors of exhibits

2 Postcards

Meridian Restaurant & Bar

New American restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects

New American comfort food in a rustic-chic space with patio

1 Postcard

Libertine

Cocktail bar · Riley

Craft cocktails, elevated bar bites in a relaxed speakeasy setting

0 Postcards

Starbucks

Coffee shop · Westover

Offers Blonde & signature espresso, seasonal Frappuccinos, pastries

6 Postcards

BODHI

Cocktail bar · Indianapolis

Upscale Thai destination with craft beers & cocktails

5 Postcards

Provision

Restaurant · Keystone At the Crossing

Imaginative New American dishes & wine list in industrial-chic

2 Postcards

Military Park

Memorial park · Canal Walk

Historic park hosting festivals, events, canal walks, and paddle boats

1 Postcard

Root & Bone - Indianapolis

Southern restaurant (US) · Mozel Sander Projects

Southern comfort food with a chic vibe, creative cocktails

8 Postcards

Jimmy's Diner

Diner · University Heights

Breakfast served all day, homestyle comfort food, burgers & pies

1 Postcard