Gaines Street Pies

The Best 14 Restaurants in Tallahassee, Florida | Eater Miami

"Gaines Street Pies is a top choice for a great pizza in Tallahassee. The business, started by two local guys who wanted to create a superior pizza, launched with a laid-back, comic book-themed establishment in a college town. Gaines Street Pies has grown to three pizzerias with the same fun menu choices, like the Freaks & Greeks pie with artichokes, Honey I Shrunk the Pigs Pizza with smoked andouille sausage, and the White Sword Pizza with chicken and pineapple in the Heroes and Villains section. Another option: Build a custom pie with more than two dozen regular toppings or 11 premium picks like roasted fig or truffle oil—appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and calzones round out the menu."