"With Lilly Pulitzer resort wear, loose-knit “Mackinac” sweaters, and argyle socks, there is no question that the boutique that is a part of this iconic restaurant (which came well before Chappell Roan’s Billboard hit) is one of the best places to shop on the island. But there should be a rule that to earn a Pink Pony souvenir, you need to sip a pink drink. Whether you ask to be seated outside on the beloved deck or inside where you can peep the famous mural of dancing pink horses that sits behind the bar, pick your poison — a frozen rum runner, French 75, punch, Cosmopolitan, or even a lemonade will all come in the namesake hue." - Stacey Brugeman