Bake Sale Indy

Bakery · Mayflower Meadows

1

@eater

The 38 Best Restaurants in Indianapolis, Indiana | Eater

"Cuylor Reeves left a D.C. political career to bake in New Orleans, where he learned patisserie and viennoiserie at historic eateries like Compère Lapin, Restaurant August, and La Boulangerie. Upon moving to Circle City for love, he began plying his wares at farmers markets. In 2024, he opened Bake Sale in an unassuming strip mall along Allisonville Road next to a boxing gym and a bar. In many ways, it’s the perfect location: After hitting the bag, a lot of folks could use some ginger molasses monkey bread, buttery pain au chocolat, or mini lemon king cakes. Must-try dish: Reeves makes fresh French baguettes in two sizes every morning, but get there early if you want to snag one before they sell out." - Brian Garrido

https://www.eater.com/maps/best-restaurants-indianapolis

6239 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46220 Get directions

bakesaleindy.com
@bakesaleindy

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Milktooth

Restaurant · Fletcher Place

Inventive breakfast & brunch with unique dishes, pastries, coffee & cocktails

8 Postcards

Beholder

Fine dining restaurant · Woodruff Place

World-inspired small plates feature truffle bucatini.

5 Postcards

Pier 48 Fish House and Oyster Bar

Seafood restaurant · Wholesale District

Lobster rolls, wings, clam chowder, oysters & seafood

2 Postcards

The Bristol

Apartment complex · Indianapolis

French-inspired New American dining, tasting menus, brunch

5 Postcards

The Alexander

Hotel · Indianapolis

Hotel with custom artwork, massage, bar, and dining

0 Postcards

Goose The Market

Butcher shop deli · Kingpark

Gourmet market & butcher with amazing sandwiches, wine, gelato

3 Postcards

Paco's Taqueria

Mexican restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects

Birria tacos, burritos, quesadillas, and horchata.

2 Postcards

Chin Brothers Restaurant

Burmese restaurant · Greenwood Place

Authentic Burmese & SE Asian dishes, tea, and groceries

2 Postcards

Caplinger's Fresh Catch

Seafood market · Fairwood Hills

Fresh fish market & cafe with fried seafood, sandwiches & sides

2 Postcards

The Inferno Room

Tiki bar · Fountain Square

Island-themed haunt with creative tiki cocktails & bar bites

1 Postcard