Bake Sale Indy

Bakery · Mayflower Meadows

1

@eater

"Open for: Breakfast, lunchPrice range: $Cuylor Reeves left a D.C. political career to bake in New Orleans, where he learned patisserie and viennoiserie at historic eateries like Compère Lapin, Restaurant August, and La Boulangerie. Upon moving to Circle City for love, he began plying his wares at farmers markets. In 2024, he opened Bake Sale in an unassuming strip mall along Allisonville Road next to a boxing gym and a bar. In many ways, it’s the perfect location: After hitting the bag, a lot of folks could use some ginger molasses monkey bread, buttery pain au chocolat, or mini lemon king cakes. Must-try dish: Reeves makes fresh French baguettes in two sizes every morning, but get there early if you want to snag one before they sell out." - Brian Garrido

The 38 Best Restaurants in Indianapolis, Indiana

6239 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46220 Get directions

bakesaleindy.com
@bakesaleindy

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Indianapolis City Market

Market · Mass. Ave Arts District

Step into the historic Indianapolis City Market, a vibrant food hall serving up a kaleidoscope of local eats and craft brews, where every craving finds its match.

0 Postcards

Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen

Chicken restaurant · Vertland

Dive into this Louisiana-style fast-food haven for spicy chicken, flaky biscuits, and a side of late-night convenience, though service can be hit or miss.

1 Postcard

Garden Table

Restaurant · Wellington

This cozy spot in Broadripple serves up creative New American dishes and fresh-pressed juices, making it a go-to for brunch lovers seeking healthy fare.

1 Postcard

Burgeezy

Restaurant · Upper Canal

Burgeezy is a cozy plant-based spot along Canal Walk, slinging up tasty sandwiches and vegan comfort food in a vibrant atmosphere.

1 Postcard

Indy Hostel

Hostel · Mozel Sander Projects

Bright and stylish hostel near Broad Ripple, featuring cozy common areas, bike rentals, and a friendly atmosphere that feels like a laid-back retreat.

0 Postcards

Ale Emporium

Restaurant · Allisonville

This lively sports bar serves up delicious American bites and standout pizza, making it the perfect spot for friends to cheer, eat, and unwind.

2 Postcards

Chin Brothers Restaurant

Burmese restaurant · Greenwood Place

This charming spot serves up delightful Burmese cuisine with friendly service, offering everything from rich curries to refreshing milk teas, all in a cozy atmosphere.

2 Postcards

Sidedoor Bagel

Bagel shop · Indianapolis

Sidedoor in downtown Indianapolis is your go-to bagel spot, featuring fresh, flavorful options and cozy outdoor seating perfect for chilly mornings.

2 Postcards

Livery

Latin American restaurant · Indianapolis

A chic bi-level haven with a year-round rooftop patio serving Latin staples and top-notch tequila, perfect for a vibrant night out.

2 Postcards

Caplinger's Fresh Catch

Seafood market · Fairwood Hills

This family-run fish market and cafe is the go-to spot in Central Indiana for fresh seafood and hearty sides, with a friendly vibe that keeps diners coming back for more.

2 Postcards