"Deep in the forest, near Cultus Bay, hides an ancient wooden schoolhouse-turned-gas station and mini-mart. There’s a good selection of beer and cider, which patrons then can enjoy either on a huge covered porch or what’s possibly the state’s smallest bar (the size of a walk-in closet). Bailey’s also has the best cheeseburgers on the island —juicy and enormous, piled with thick strips of bacon and Beecher’s cheese — and the porch often has live music on the weekends." - Meg van Huygen