Schmackary's

Where To Eat & Drink Before (& After) Seeing A Broadway Show, According To JoJo - New York - The Infatuation

"“They serve the best cookies I have ever had. I like to go to Schmackary’s if I need a gift, if I'm thinking of them and I'm like, ‘You deserve 12 cookies right now. You've been so good, girl.’ You can't go wrong with their chocolate chip. But what I love about them is that they'll do cookies that are associated with different shows. They had one for Shucked, which was one of my favorite shows that I saw in 2023. It was a really good corn cookie—it had corn and cornflakes and all that stuff. They had one called The Hummingbird, which was my favorite—oats, pineapple, coconut, banana, toasted pecans, and a Southern cream cheese frosting. That plus a coffee, that's all I need.”" - brennan carley