
5
"When served warm, the vanilla fragrance wafting off this hefty cookie could lure us into traffic. Unfortunately, the smell is writing checks that the taste can't cash. Especially once it's reached room temperature, the cookie tastes too sweet and artificial, with poor-quality chocolate. We cannot in good conscience give it five big booms—that’s for the chicken bake." - molly fitzpatrick, bryan kim, willa moore, will hartman, sonal shah