Brooklyn Square Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Toms River

2

@infatuation

"You no doubt have a friend that will invite you to their “shore house” this summer and after hours of driving, you’ll find yourself in a beachless neighborhood on the west side of the Barnegat Bay in Toms River. The bad news is that your assumed summer beach adventure has led you to a land of strip malls you could have found 15 minutes over the George Washington Bridge. But the good news is that Brooklyn Square Pizza is nearby. This place specializes in square pies, layered with pecorino on top of slightly sweet sauce and mozzarella on a big cloud of dough dusted with sesame seeds. It’s like taking the subway to Bensonhurst, but without having to deal with the N train delays from midtown." - Michael Sinatra

Brooklyn Square Pizza Review - Toms River - Jersey Shore - The Infatuation
Emily Schindler

1898 Hinds Rd, Toms River, NJ 08753 Get directions

brooklynsquarenj.com
@brooklynsquarepizza

2 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

Ob-Co's Donuts

Donut shop · Toms River

OB-CO’s is a beloved Jersey Shore spot serving over-the-top donuts like apple fritters and Boston creams, drawing lines of eager fans since '53.

2 Postcards

Chang Wang

Chinese restaurant · Toms River

Cozy spot serving up fresh Chinese dishes and sushi, perfect for any meal from lunch to late-night cravings, beloved by locals for its tasty options.

0 Postcards

Insectropolis

Museum · Toms River

Discover a playful haven for bug enthusiasts at Insectropolis, where you can interact with live critters and delve into their fascinating world.

1 Postcard

Vesper Tavern

American restaurant · Newark

Vesper Tavern serves up solid American comfort food and drinks in a laid-back airport setting, with a quirky kiosk ordering system for pre-flight bites.

3 Postcards

Taqueria Rendon (Ocean City)

Restaurant · Ocean City

Nestled in the Surf Mall, this vibrant Mexican eatery dishes up hearty tacos, burritos, and bowls that redefine boardwalk bites with bold flavors and friendly vibes.

1 Postcard

Shake Shack

Restaurant · Monmouth County

Hip, counter-serve chain for gourmet takes on fast-food classics like burgers & frozen custard.

2 Postcards

The Parker House

Seafood restaurant · Sea Girt

Victorian beach home featuring a porch bar, relaxed tavern with seafood fare & an upstairs club.

3 Postcards

Forte Pizzeria

Italian restaurant · Caldwell

At this casual Italian spot, enjoy authentic dishes and pizza in a laid-back atmosphere perfect for grabbing a bite before a concert.

1 Postcard

Cafe Loren

American restaurant · Avalon

Upscale-casual BYOB restaurant cooking modern American fare for 30+ years. Open seasonally.

4 Postcards

R BAR

Bar · Asbury Park

R Bar is a vibrant American restaurant and bar in Asbury Park, where you can savor mouthwatering beignets and gumbo while enjoying live jazz in a relaxed, colorful space.

3 Postcards