Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant

American restaurant · Cape May

2

@infatuation

"Peter Shields Inn is one of Cape May’s iconic dining destinations. It’s popular both for its menu of elaborate classics made with local produce and for its location: a stately Georgian revival a stone’s throw from the dunes. Ask for a table on the open-air front porch, under a black and white striped awning, and wait out the sunset with freshly-shucked local oysters and grilled lobsters. The restaurant is BYOB, but if you forget a bottle you can still pair the oysters with a glass of sauvignon blanc—they sell a small selection from the nearby Cape May Winery." - regan stephens, candis mclean, sydney mcelwee, tonya russell

The 20 Best Restaurants In Cape May 2024
Emily Schindler

1301 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204 Get directions

petershieldsinn.com
@petershieldsinnandrestaurant

2 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

The Blue Pig Tavern

American restaurant · Cape May

Updated American fare served on the patio or in the warm & rustic dining room of an 1800s hotel.

3 Postcards

The Chalfonte Hotel

Hotel · Cape May

Step into the charming Chalfonte Hotel, where vintage vibes meet ocean views, inviting you to relax on porches with live music and enjoy cozy, rustic rooms.

1 Postcard

Maison Bleue Bistro

French restaurant · Cape May

Maison Bleue is a charming French bistro at The Hugh B&B, showcasing seasonal fare and a cozy atmosphere ideal for a romantic night out—don’t forget to BYOB!

2 Postcards

The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar

American restaurant · Cape May

Buzzing breakfast-to-dinner bistro offering American fare, a bar & frequent live music in cozy digs.

3 Postcards

Tisha's Fine Dining

American restaurant · Cape May

Tisha’s is a charming Cape May staple offering a delightful mix of New American dishes and classic burgers, all wrapped in a cozy atmosphere near the Washington Street mall.

2 Postcards

Ebbitt Room

Restaurant · Cape May

Well-appointed, luxe eatery & tavern offering seasonal, farm-to-table New American cuisine & drinks.

6 Postcards

Dockside Dave’s Seafood Market

Fresh food market · Cape May

Dockside Dave’s is a charming seafood market serving up fresh catches and tasty sandwiches like lobster rolls that make every meal an easy delight.

1 Postcard

Harriet Tubman Museum of New Jersey

Museum · Cape May

The Harriet Tubman Museum in Cape May offers an engaging, interactive journey through the life of this iconic abolitionist and her ties to the area.

2 Postcards

Fine Fellows Creamery

Ice cream shop · Cape May

Step into Fine Fellows Creamery in Cape May for a vibrant scoop of happiness, where inventive flavors and a welcoming vibe make every treat a celebration.

1 Postcard

The Cheese Shop

Cheese shop · Cape May

At this charming cheese shop in Washington Street Mall, find gourmet cheeses, made-to-order sandwiches, and easy charcuterie boards for all your beach day cravings.

2 Postcards