Black Whale Bar & Fish House

Seafood restaurant · Beach Haven

3

@infatuation

"Black Whale is less than a block from Parker’s Garage, and both spots are from the same team, but deciding between the two is pretty straightforward. If you want dinner, go to Parker’s Garage, and if you want drinks and snacks, go to Black Whale. This walk-in-only spot (except for groups of eight or more) is almost always packed, but if you get there early enough or wait around long enough, you’ll be able to get a high-top or seats at the horseshoe bar. This is an especially good move during Happy Hour (3-6pm on weekdays), when there are $3 beers, $4 wine and well drinks, and discounted food, like $1 oysters and big plates of not-overly-fried calamari." - Matt Tervooren, Tonya Russell

Where To Eat Down The Shore: Long Beach Island - New York - The Infatuation
@TheInfatuation

100 N Pennsylvania Ave, Beach Haven, NJ 08008 Get directions

blackwhalebar.com

3 Postcards

Reserve
See full details

More Places For You

Pearl Street Market

Seafood market · Beach Haven

At Pearl Street Market in Beach Haven, you’ll find mouthwatering deli and seafood sandwiches, plus tasty breakfast wraps in a cozy, outdoor space.

3 Postcards

Panzone's Pizza & Pasta

Italian restaurant · Beach Haven

At Panzone's, the fresh pizza and vibrant menu shine, making it a go-to spot in LBI for hearty meals and welcoming vibes that keep diners coming back.

2 Postcards

The Gables Historic Inn & Restaurant

Fine dining restaurant · Beach Haven

Escape to The Gables, an elegant Victorian B&B where polished rooms meet a stunning dining experience amid lush gardens, perfect for special occasions.

2 Postcards

Dock & Claw Clam Bar

Restaurant · Beach Haven

Dock & Claw combines nostalgic clam shack charm with a vibrant vibe, serving up fresh seafood, creative dishes, and a BYOB policy perfect for fun gatherings.

2 Postcards

Holiday Snack Bar

American restaurant · Beach Haven

Holiday Snack Bar is a nostalgic treasure serving griddle-cooked burgers and homemade pies since 1948, perfect for family meals and milkshakes.

3 Postcards

Uncle Will's

Breakfast restaurant · Beach Haven

Uncle Will's, a beloved diner in Beach Haven since '65, offers a welcoming vibe with hearty breakfasts, local wines, and charming retro decor.

3 Postcards

Parker's Garage & Oyster Saloon

Seafood restaurant · Beach Haven

Chill spot with a throwback vibe dishing out a varied seafood menu, known for standout appetizers and sunset views over the bay.

3 Postcards

The Chicken or the Egg - Beach Haven

Chicken restaurant · Beach Haven

The Chicken or the Egg, affectionately known as Chegg, is a vibrant 24/7 diner where you can savor hearty breakfast classics and legendary wings.

4 Postcards

Barry's Do Me A Flavor

Restaurant · Beach Haven

A casual gem in Beach Haven, Barry's serves up classic LBI vibes with a menu packed with burgers, cheesesteaks, and delightful ice cream treats.

3 Postcards

Bird and Betty's

Restaurant · Beach Haven

At Bird and Betty's, enjoy a lively vibe with friends, savoring quality seafood and tasty wood-fired pizzas, all while taking in stunning sunset views.

3 Postcards