5

Schmackary's

Bakery · Midtown West ·

Schmackary's

Bakery · Midtown West ·
@eater
391,688 Postcards · 10,992 Cities

The Cookies That Starred in ‘Only Murders in the Building’ Are Coming to San Diego | Eater San Diego

"I first encountered a viral East Coast cookie when Schmackary’s was name-dropped throughout season three of Hulu’s Only Murders in the Building and featured memorably in the scene where Paul Rudd’s character ruefully gobbles a cookie decorated with the cursed “Death Rattle” logo. Founded by aspiring actor Zachary Schmahl in his Hell’s Kitchen apartment, the shop opened a storefront in NYC’s Theatre District in 2012 and is known as the “official cookie of Broadway,” often producing limited-edition themed cookies to tie in with big stage performances. Its menu rotates through more than 100 flavors, with bestsellers like Funfetti, Cookie Dough, Sweet Corn, and Caramel Apple Crisp. After beginning to franchise in 2023, the brand is working with San Diegan Sharian Lott to open a San Diego storefront paired with a West Coast production facility expected by the end of 2024." - Candice Woo

https://sandiego.eater.com/2024/4/17/24132993/schmackarys-cookies-dessert-shop-new-york-city-expanding-new-opening-san-diego

Information

Bakery offering 45+ cookie varieties, including gluten-free

cookies
chocolate chip cookie
broadway show
unique flavors
friendly service
sweet
peanut butter cookie
funfetti cookie
Google Rating
4.5 (2.4K)
Yelp Rating
4.2
Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in
Featured in Eater
Featured in

362 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036 Get directions

$1–10

Order delivery
See Menu
Credit card accepted
Debit card accepted
Contactless accepted
Free street parking
Free Wi-Fi
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by Infatuation - Reviews
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
See full details

5

Information

Bakery offering 45+ cookie varieties, including gluten-free

cookies
chocolate chip cookie
broadway show
unique flavors
friendly service
sweet
peanut butter cookie
funfetti cookie
Google Rating
4.5 (2.4K)
Yelp Rating
4.2
Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in
Featured in Eater
Featured in

362 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036 Get directions

$1–10

Order delivery
See Menu
Credit card accepted
Debit card accepted
Contactless accepted
Free street parking
Free Wi-Fi
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by Infatuation - Reviews
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
Schmackary's by null
See full details

More Places For You

Claudette’s

Moroccan restaurant · Arverne

Middle Eastern & Moroccan fare, bowls, pitas, juices, cookies

5 Postcards

Blue Blossom 青花

Chinese restaurant · Midtown West

Elegant Chinese dining with Peking duck & fiery chicken

8 Postcards

Hole In The Wall

Restaurant · Williamsburg

Australian-inspired cafe serving coffee, brunch, cocktails & dinner

10 Postcards

Komune

Clothing store · Lower East Side

Showcasing emerging designers, unique pieces, and exceptional service

1 Postcard

Phil’s

Bar · Bushwick

Wine bar with hot dogs, grilled cheese, and pretzels

5 Postcards

DAIGO Sushi Roll Bar

Sushi takeaway · Park Slope

Sashimi-forward rolls, warm rice, quick takeout, fresh fish

2 Postcards

Coral Omakase at Point Seven

Sushi restaurant · Midtown East

Upscale Omakase sushi with Tokyo market ingredients

2 Postcards

Grand Tea & Imports 佛運玄 | 好茶水

Tea store · Lower East Side

Fine teas, tea wares, Buddhist art, traditional gifts, incense

3 Postcards

Sailor's Choice

Restaurant · Chelsea

New England seafood shack with lobster BLT, fish & chips, oysters

3 Postcards

Bánh Anh Em

Vietnamese restaurant · East Village

Bánh mì made with crackly, airy house-baked baguettes

31 Postcards