St. Elmo Steak House

Steak house · Wholesale District

5

@eater

The 36 Essential Indianapolis Restaurants

"One of the oldest restaurants in the city serves some of the best steaks, chops, and seafood in Indianapolis. Since 1902, St. Elmo has been cooking up premium cuts of meat in the heart of downtown. For appetizers, get the shrimp cocktail in St. Elmo’s famous signature sauce, popular for its kick from the horseradish. That’s just one of an array of house-made sauces to accompany entrees way beyond A1, with options like creamy horseradish, truffle dijonaise, remoulade, and more. St. Elmo is a must-stop for any visitor to Indianapolis who loves steak or needs to splurge on an elegant white tablecloth dinner." - Mike Gillis

https://www.eater.com/maps/the-eater-indianapolis-heatmap-where-to-eat-right-now-2
David Pluimer

127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225 Get directions

stelmos.com
@stelmosteakhouse

5 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge

Steak house · Southeast

Geraldine's serves up prime steaks and elegant seafood in a cozy, speakeasy vibe, complete with live jazz that makes every dinner feel special.

1 Postcard

Petite Chou Bistro & Champagne Bar

French restaurant · Wellington

Petite Chou is a cozy French bistro in Broad Ripple serving scrumptious classics like steak frites, crepes, and duck fat fries with perfectly curated Champagne cocktails.

2 Postcards

Bluebeard

Fine dining restaurant · Fletcher Place

Bluebeard serves inventive New American bites and craft cocktails in a cozy, book-lined 1924 warehouse with a lively patio vibe.

4 Postcards

The Commodore

Bar · Fountain Square

Hidden in Fountain Square, The Commodore serves up craft cocktails in a vintage speakeasy vibe, complete with jazz, themed nights, and expertly skilled bartenders.

1 Postcard

PB&J Factory

Sandwich shop · Downtown

PB & J Factory in the West Loop serves gourmet, customizable grilled PB&Js with inventive spreads and toppings in a fun, casual shipping container spot.

1 Postcard

JW Marriott Indianapolis

Hotel · Canal Walk

Sleek high-rise hotel with luxe rooms, skywalk to convention center, Italian eats, sports bar, Starbucks, and a lively downtown Indy vibe.

2 Postcards

Indy Hostel

Hostel · Mozel Sander Projects

This vibrant hostel near Broad Ripple offers comfortable, stylish accommodations, a chill atmosphere, and bike rentals, perfect for budget travelers.

0 Postcards

Apocalypse Burger

Hamburger restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects

At Apocalypse Burger, the vibes are as bold as the flavors—expect juicy smash burgers made with high-quality ingredients, crispy loaded fries, and quirky decor that screams anarchy while keeping it all deliciously straightforward.

2 Postcards

Indianapolis City Market

Market · Mass. Ave Arts District

Step into the historic Indianapolis City Market, a vibrant food hall serving up a kaleidoscope of local eats and craft brews, where every craving finds its match.

0 Postcards

Gather 22

Restaurant · Indianapolis

Gather 22 is a vibrant eatery with a trendy vibe, perfect for any occasion, serving up inventive pizzas, hearty brunch options, and creative cocktails alongside a welcoming outdoor space.

1 Postcard