Nicholas Creamery

Ice cream shop · Atlantic Highlands

2

@infatuation

"So you decided you were going to try to outsmart the shore traffic and take the ferry from Manhattan to the beach. Well played. What you didn’t bank on was roasting in the sun on the boat for 40 minutes to find yourself reaching the shores of Jersey in a translucent sweat-drenched shirt. The good news is the Seastreak landed in the Highlands and you’re a few minutes from an ice cream therapy session at Nicholas Creamery. Nicholas is a name that for years was synonymous with fine dining in New Jersey. They’ve taken that same local ingredient sourcing and approach to ice cream making with flavors like chocolate caramel pretzel, honey lavender, and brown sugar cookie dough, and pairing them with made-to-order waffle cones or as the centerpiece in their fantastic milkshakes." - Michael Sinatra

Nicholas Creamery - Review - Atlantic Highlands - Jersey Shore - The Infatuation

84 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 Get directions

nicholascreamery.com
@nicholascreamery

2 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

Una Pizza Napoletana

Restaurant · Atlantic Highlands

Una Pizza Napoletana brings Anthony Mangieri's renowned Neapolitan pies back to the Jersey Shore, where uncompromising quality meets a casual dining vibe.

1 Postcard

Flour on First

Bakery · Atlantic Highlands

Nestled a five-minute stroll from the Atlantic Highlands ferry, Flour on First dazzles with artisan cakes, indulgent pastries, and savory delights, all crafted with love.

1 Postcard

Sariling Atin

Grocery store · Bergenfield

Sariiling Atin is a Filipino grocery gem where quick bites like flavorful lechon kawali and savory pancit await—just be ready for a mixed vibe.

1 Postcard

La Victoria

Colombian restaurant · Clifton

Caseros La Victoria is a quaint gem in Clifton, NJ, serving up fresh, authentic Colombian dishes crafted from traditional recipes with a focus on homemade flavors.

1 Postcard

Mamak House

Malaysian restaurant · Jersey City

Mamak House is a spacious, laid-back gem on the Hackensack River, dishing out vibrant Malaysian cuisine alongside tempting Thai and Chinese options.

2 Postcards

Fort Lee

· Fort Lee

Fort Lee, perched on the Palisades overlooking the Hudson, blends charming borough vibes with an upcoming upscale chophouse scene.

0 Postcards

Porta Asbury Park

Italian restaurant · Asbury Park

This spacious pizzeria near the beach serves up vibrant Neapolitan pies, delicious pastas, and cocktails, all in a lively outdoor setting.

6 Postcards

The Grove Station

Gastropub · Jersey City

A chic hub featuring a sunny patio, cozy coffee shop, and a lively New American bistro, perfect for friendly gatherings and casual indulgence.

2 Postcards

Cardinal Provisions

Brunch restaurant · Asbury Park

This charming brunch spot features inviting brick walls and a menu filled with creative breakfast sandwiches and dishes, perfect for a leisurely meal indoors or al fresco.

8 Postcards

SeaGrass Restaurant

Seafood restaurant · Ocean Grove

Dive into SeaGrass in Ocean Grove, a cozy BYOB spot where sustainable seafood meets hearty American fare, all wrapped in charming nautical decor.

1 Postcard