"Brooklyn Farmacy does not make their own ice cream, which would normally disqualify it from this list. But this Carroll Gardens soda counter in an old apothecary shop is arguably the most pleasant atmosphere to eat a giant sundae, so we’ll give them a pass. Plus, those sundaes—there are 12 specialty combos—are built with Adirondack Creamery’s excellent, velvety ice cream. We also love their shakes and egg creams." - bryan kim, willa moore, sonal shah, molly fitzpatrick, kenny yang