Best Pizza in Colorado Springs

Old Colorado City’s standard-bearer for wood-fired Neapolitan pies, fired in a locally built oven with carefully sourced toppings. Springs Magazine and The Gazette spotlight its craftsmanship and enduring appeal. ([springsmag.com](https://springsmag.com/best-pizzas-colorado-springs/), [gazette.com](https://gazette.com/dining/pizzeria-rustica-a-slice-of-italy-in-colorado-springs-dining-review/article_21708a94-e533-11e9-b1d9-977097b7b44a.html?utm_source=openai))

Foldable New York slices with a community-driven story; crowned winner in Springs Magazine’s New York style test and a citywide People’s Choice favorite. Two locations keep lines moving without losing soul. ([springsmag.com](https://springsmag.com/new-york-style-pizza-colorado-springs/?utm_source=openai))

Family-run since the ’70s, this counter-service classic is locals’ go-to for thin-crust pies. Recent honors from FOX21’s Best of the Best and earlier praise from The Gazette back up its staying power. ([fox21news.com](https://www.fox21news.com/best-of-the-best/best-of-the-best-pizza-leon-gessi-new-york-pizza/?utm_source=openai), [gazette.com](https://gazette.com/arts-entertainment/dining-review-longtime-colorado-springs-favorite-leon-gessi-irresistible-for-more-than-pizza/article_f69342e2-ccb7-11e8-87e2-5cb9017bdf7c.html?utm_source=openai))

Roman-style, rectangular pies with a three-day sourdough and Italian pantry; a neighborhood hub from the Blue Star Group. Recognized by Springs Magazine and warmly reviewed by The Gazette. ([springsmag.com](https://springsmag.com/best-pizzas-colorado-springs/), [gazette.com](https://gazette.com/arts-entertainment/dining-review-enjoy-roman-style-pizza-and-pasta-at-stellina-in-colorado-springs/article_eada8406-e334-11eb-bb31-83315874e42a.html?utm_source=openai))

Chef-driven 16-inch pies, pepperoni rolls, and seasonal specials anchor this Rockrimmon favorite. The Gazette says it rises above the norm, and Springs Magazine includes it among top local picks. ([gazette.com](https://gazette.com/premium/pizza-thats-a-slice-above-the-rest-in-colorado-springs-dining-review/article_c0d3aa74-736b-11ee-9625-83bc9d99c85a.html?utm_source=openai), [springsmag.com](https://springsmag.com/best-pizzas-colorado-springs/))

A downtown institution where solar-baked pies meet bookstore culture and live events. Springs Magazine marked its 50-year milestone, reflecting deep roots and steady crowds. ([springsmag.com](https://springsmag.com/poor-richards-celebrates-50-years-in-colorado-springs/?utm_source=openai))

Carryout-only stalwart since the 1980s turning out hand‑spun pies, creative specials, and hearty salads. The Gazette praises its vibrant flavors and value. ([gazette.com](https://gazette.com/premium/vibrant-flavors-served-up-at-roadrunner-pizza-pasta-in-colorado-springs-dining-review/article_46ccb898-c802-11ed-952d-d35ab820b32b.html?utm_source=openai))

Detroit-style slabs with caramelized-cheese edges inside the Ivywild School. The Gazette called out its Motor City crunch when it landed in town. ([gazette.com](https://gazette.com/arts-entertainment/detroit-style-pizza-awaits-at-colorado-springs-restaurant-pikes-pick/article_09f3f32a-9d5a-11eb-addf-433183cc61ee.html?utm_source=openai))

A third‑generation local family refashioned a 1970s favorite into fast‑fired Neapolitan pies downtown; featured by KRDO and still popular with students and families. ([krdo.com](https://krdo.com/news/top-stories/2022/02/09/national-pizza-day-one-colorado-springs-pizzeria-preps-for-superbowl-rush/?utm_source=openai))

One day a week, this artisan bakery turns out limited, blistered pizzas from its deck oven—an insider ritual that Springs Magazine says is worth the line. ([springsmag.com](https://springsmag.com/elevated-pizza/?utm_source=openai))

Locally owned slice shops known for hand‑tossed NY pies; expanded across town while keeping a neighborhood feel. The Gazette has covered its growth and reader acclaim. ([gazette.com](https://gazette.com/business/2-new-york-style-pizza-restaurants-add-locations-in-colorado-springs/article_394255ea-82ca-11eb-bf0f-3b239f974a0a.html?utm_source=openai))