New Bethel Ordinary

Pizza restaurant · Wanamaker

1

@postcardnews

Franklin Township favorite with party-cut, topping-loaded pies that feed a crowd and fuel lively local debates about Indy-style pizza. Frequently mentioned by local outlets and beloved by southside families for value, nostalgia, and sheer heft.

https://indytoday.6amcity.com/city-guide/live/best-pizza-indianapolis-in
Best Pizza in Indianapolis (2025)
View this post on Instagram

A post shared by New Bethel Ordinary (@nbopizza)

8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239 Get directions

nbopizza.net
@nbopizza

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Gallery Bistro & Bar

Restaurant · Wholesale District

European fare, pastries, coffee & full bar with a chic vibe

3 Postcards

Café Babette

Pastry shop · Downtown

Flaky, crispy pastries, brown butter croissant cinnamon roll

1 Postcard

Fat Dan's Deli

American restaurant · Mass Ave Arts District

Chicago-themed spot with burgers, hot dogs & smoked meats

1 Postcard

Yaso Jamaican Grill

Jamaican restaurant · Southeast

Jerk chicken, oxtail, curry dishes, patties, drinks, & rum cake

2 Postcards

Ripple Bagel and Deli

Bagel shop · Wellington

Steamed bagel sandwiches, soups, salads, and friendly service

2 Postcards

Nowhere Special

Bar · Riley

Dimly lit basement speakeasy with creative cocktails, dumplings, ribs

2 Postcards

Futuro

Pizza restaurant · Indianapolis

Detroit-style pizza with creative toppings & crispy crust

2 Postcards

The Bristol

Apartment complex · Indianapolis

Seasonal tasting menu with French techniques & New American flavors

5 Postcards

St. Elmo Steak House

Steak house · Wholesale District

Historic steakhouse serving famous spicy shrimp cocktail

6 Postcards

The Cheesecake Factory

Restaurant · Keystone At the Crossing

Massive menu, sizable portions, signature cheesecake, great for groups

3 Postcards