Sam’s Square Pie

Pizza restaurant · Indy East

4

@postcardnews

Near-eastside pan pizza with a faithful following for caramelized-edge, sauce-forward squares. Featured in Eater’s list of essential Indy restaurants and spotlighted by local TV segments for meaty, memory-lane flavors made in small, craveable batches.

https://www.eater.com/maps/best-restaurants-indianapolis
Best Pizza in Indianapolis (2025)
View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Sam’s Square Pie (@sams_square_pie)

2829 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46201, USA Get directions

order.toasttab.com
@sams_square_pie

4 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

Monon Coffee Company

Coffee shop · Wellington

Artisan coffee, rotating lattes, vegan options, local art hub

1 Postcard

Long's Bakery

Bakery · Glendale

Cash-only institution serving delicious yeast & cake donuts, cakes

3 Postcards

Claire's

Ear piercing service · Vertland

Jewelry, fashion accessories, beauty products, and ear piercing services

1 Postcard

Strange Bird

Tiki bar · Irvington

Ramen, oysters, and tiki cocktails with a tropical vibe

3 Postcards

Ale Emporium

Restaurant · Allisonville

World-famous Hermanaki wings, pizza & sports bar atmosphere

3 Postcards

The Bristol

Apartment complex · Indianapolis

Seasonal tasting menu with French techniques & New American flavors

7 Postcards

PB&J Factory

Sandwich shop · Downtown

Gourmet PB&J sandwiches with endless customization options

1 Postcard

JW Marriott Indianapolis

Hotel · Canal Walk

Upscale hotel with Italian restaurant, sports bar, and fitness center.

2 Postcards

Sam's Silver Circle

Bar · Southeast

Neighborhood dive bar with pizza, beer, karaoke & trivia

2 Postcards

Milktooth

Restaurant · Fletcher Place

Inventive brunch, espresso & cocktails with seasonal, local ingredients

9 Postcards