2

Red Key Tavern

Bar & grill · Mozel Sander Projects ·

Red Key Tavern

Bar & grill · Mozel Sander Projects ·
@postcardnews
22,027 Postcards · 1,950 Cities

This Meridian-Kessler classic is beloved for its griddled cheeseburger, jukebox of Big Band 45s, and steadfast house rules. Celebrated by Indianapolis Monthly and even noted in The New York Times’ travel coverage, it’s pure Indy character on a bun.

https://www.redkeytavern.com/
Best Burgers in Indianapolis (2025)

Information

Cash-only neighborhood saloon with legendary burgers & jukebox

cash only
burgers
history
neighborhood bar
dive bar
affordable prices
friendly staff
potato salad
Google Rating
4.6 (319)
Yelp Rating
4.1
Placeholder

5170 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205 Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
Cash only
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Cozy
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
See full details

2

Information

Cash-only neighborhood saloon with legendary burgers & jukebox

cash only
burgers
history
neighborhood bar
dive bar
affordable prices
friendly staff
potato salad
Google Rating
4.6 (319)
Yelp Rating
4.1
Placeholder

5170 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205 Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
Cash only
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Cozy
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
See full details

More Places For You

Milktooth

Restaurant · Fletcher Place

Inventive breakfast & brunch with seasonal waffles, Dutch babies, cocktails

10 Postcards

Smoking Goose Meatery

Meat wholesaler · Indianapolis

Artisan meatery with unique flavors, charcuterie, and tasting events

3 Postcards

Siam Square

Thai restaurant · Fountain Square

Thai specialties like pad thai, drunken noodles, coconut curry

3 Postcards

Shapiro's Delicatessen

Deli · Pogue's Run

Kosher-style deli classics, huge sandwiches, cafeteria style

4 Postcards

The District Tap

Gastropub · Wholesale District

Craft beer, burgers, wings, and live music in the Wholesale District

1 Postcard

Yats

Cajun restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects

Hearty Cajun & Creole plates served over rice with warm bread

2 Postcards

Indianapolis International Airport

International airport · Indianapolis

Airport with art, local shops, food, and free WiFi.

4 Postcards

McDonald's

Fast food restaurant · Lafayette Square

Classic burgers & fries, with suggested hand pies

1 Postcard

Half Liter Brewery, Bar, & BBQ

Barbecue restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects

BBQ, beer garden, shared plates, salads, dog-friendly patio

2 Postcards

Sugar Factory - Indianapolis

American restaurant · Wholesale District

Sweets, monster burgers, and Insta-worthy goblets

1 Postcard