"It’s worth a trip to the ATM to visit this cash-only ice cream shop in Edgartown. Order flavors like black sesame and Chilmark Coffee cold brew soft serve, or choose from homemade hard ice cream flavors like Southern peach, sea salt caramel truffle, and pistachio. Of course, there’s nothing wrong with a classic chocolate or vanilla scoop, too. Be sure to order one of their homemade waffle cones." - Celina Colby