"The view from this waterfront setting on Montauk’s Fort Pond Bay is one of the most spectacular in the Hamptons and draws crowds, especially at sunset. Apart from lobster rolls and burgers, portions are mainly family style, and the massive Lobster Cobb Salad with huge chinks of crustacean, and the 2 pound grilled market fish are legendary. Rose is so popular here that this lobster deck has its own branded bottles." - Beth Landman