Roberta's

Italian restaurant · Montauk

1

@infatuation

"The Brooklyn favorite known for its wood-fired pizzas has a new year-round outpost, in the space that used to be Arbor, just outside town by the train station. They’ve come a long way from their original Bushwick-based converted warehouse, but this spot feels somewhat similar to their newer location in Domino Park. Expect a mix of current Brooklynites, former Brooklynites relocated to the suburbs, and wannabe Brooklynites all vying for pizzas like the Bee Sting, Famous Original, and Ursula’s Parade. " - Melissa Kravitz Hoeffner, Team Infatuation

The 19 Best Restaurants In Montauk - New York - The Infatuation
Emily Schindler

240 Firestone Rd, Montauk, NY 11954 Get directions

robertaspizza.com
@robertaspizza

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

The Surf Lodge

Resort hotel · Montauk

Nestled on Fort Pond, this vibrant hotel-cum-nightclub blends beachy vibes with eclectic dining and top-notch live music for a truly unforgettable summer bash.

6 Postcards

Westlake Fish House

Seafood restaurant · Montauk

Nestled by the docks of Westlake Marina, this lively seafood joint serves up fresh catches and sushi alongside live music and a casual, sun-soaked vibe.

2 Postcards

Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum

Historical place museum · Montauk

Perched at the eastern tip of Long Island, the historic Montauk Point Lighthouse offers stunning ocean views and a rich maritime museum experience.

1 Postcard

668 The Gig Shack

New American restaurant · Montauk

The Gig Shack serves up eclectic American comfort food with a relaxed surf shack vibe, complete with live music and standout dishes like pulled pork empanadas and lobster rolls.

2 Postcards

Herb's Market

Deli · Montauk

A beloved family-run deli and butcher shop that’s a go-to for epic fried chicken, hearty sandwiches, and perfect beach picnic provisions.

2 Postcards

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Hotel · Montauk

Gurney's Montauk Resort offers a stylish, beachfront escape with stunning ocean views, cozy cottages, and a luxurious spa, perfect for a summer getaway.

12 Postcards

Ditch Plains

Beaches · Montauk

This popular vacation spot boasts sandy surf beaches, dramatic cliffs, and the beloved local snack shack, Ditch Witch, perfect for families and surfers alike.

2 Postcards

Sel Rrose Montauk

Restaurant · Montauk

Step into Sel Rrose, a Parisian-inspired gem where you can savor fresh oysters, inventive small plates, and refreshing cocktails in a vibrant, stylish setting.

4 Postcards

Hideaway Montauk

Mexican restaurant · Montauk

Nestled in Cove Marina, The Hideaway serves up vibrant Mexican eats, fresh seafood, and cocktails in a laid-back setting perfect for families and furry friends.

4 Postcards

Seaside House Bar

Sushi restaurant · Montauk

Nestled in Montauk, this charming sushi spot offers a delightful array of creative rolls and a welcoming outdoor vibe perfect for dining with your pup.

3 Postcards