Nicholas Creamery

Ice cream shop · Atlantic Highlands

2

@infatuation

"So you decided to try to outsmart the shore traffic and take the ferry from Manhattan to the beach. Well played. What you didn't bank on was roasting in the sun for 40 minutes to find yourself reaching the shores of Jersey in a translucent sweat-drenched shirt. The good news is that you’re a few minutes from an ice cream therapy session at Nicholas Creamery. Nicholas is a name that for years was synonymous with seasonal fine dining in New Jersey, but now they’ve taken that same local ingredient sourcing approach to ice cream. Expect flavors like chocolate caramel pretzel, honey lavender, and brown sugar cookie dough, and enjoy them all in made-to-order waffle cones or as the centerpiece in their fantastic milkshakes. " - Michael Sinatra

Where To Eat Down The Shore: Atlantic Highlands To Seaside Heights - New York - The Infatuation

84 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 Get directions

nicholascreamery.com
@nicholascreamery

2 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

Flour on First

Bakery · Atlantic Highlands

Nestled a five-minute stroll from the Atlantic Highlands ferry, Flour on First dazzles with artisan cakes, indulgent pastries, and savory delights, all crafted with love.

1 Postcard

Una Pizza Napoletana

Restaurant · Atlantic Highlands

Una Pizza Napoletana brings Anthony Mangieri's renowned Neapolitan pies back to the Jersey Shore, where uncompromising quality meets a casual dining vibe.

1 Postcard

Suburban Diner

Diner · Paramus

A nostalgic diner with a modern twist, The Suburban serves classic 24-hour comfort food like burgers and breakfast all day, with a cozy vibe and friendly service.

2 Postcards

Wok Star Kitchen

Chinese restaurant · Roseland

Wok Star is your go-to for a lively family-friendly vibe, serving hand-pulled noodles and all your favorite Chinese-American classics.

2 Postcards

Fornos of Spain

Spanish restaurant · Newark

Step into Fornos of Spain for a chic Spanish feast in Newark, where flavorful dishes, generous portions, and warm service make every meal memorable.

2 Postcards

Dimaio's

Italian restaurant · Union County

Dimaio's is a cozy Italian gem in Berkeley Heights serving up delightful homemade pastas and savory meats, all in a welcoming BYOB setting.

1 Postcard

bwè kafe

Coffee shop · Hoboken

This spacious, ethical coffee shop offers great brews, cozy corners to kick back, and a commitment to giving back to Haiti.

3 Postcards

McWhorter Barbecue

Barbecue restaurant · Newark

Step into this cozy corner joint in Newark, where the cash-only menu boasts juicy Portuguese-style grilled chicken and massive portions of BBQ delights.

2 Postcards

The Chalfonte Hotel

Hotel · Cape May

Step into the charming Chalfonte Hotel, where vintage vibes meet ocean views, inviting you to relax on porches with live music and enjoy cozy, rustic rooms.

1 Postcard

Mamoun's Falafel

Mediterranean restaurant · New Brunswick

Longtime local Middle Eastern chain serving falafel, shawarma, kebabs & more in a traditional space.

1 Postcard