Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis (2025)

Four generations have kept this 1913 family haunt alive with sweet-sauced classics, checkered-table nostalgia, and loyal regulars. Longtime locals cite it as the city’s Italian soul; dinner here even earned a nod in The New York Times’ 36 Hours feature.

Set inside a 1920s Mediterranean-style villa, this beloved spot turns out generous, comforting plates and romantic patio evenings. Frequently praised by Indianapolis Monthly and often mentioned by local critics for atmosphere as much as the red-sauce favorites.

Reopened by descendants of a 1930s original, Iozzo’s blends family lore with polished Italian-American cooking—think meatball martinis, ricotta gnocchi, and a lively courtyard. Regularly recommended by local media and a downtown favorite for pre-show dinners.

An Indianapolis fixture since 1951, Capri delivers house-made pastas, a deep cellar, and old-world service in a warm, fireplace-lit dining room. It’s a frequent pick in local dining guides and an enduring choice for celebrations.

Run by the Pizzi family since 1979, Ambrosia anchors Indy’s Italian scene with Ligurian-leaning pastas, a welcoming neighborhood vibe, and a loyal following. Frequently highlighted by Indianapolis Monthly and trusted by locals for date nights and milestones.

A Northside go-to for fine Italian, Sangiovese pairs a cozy, refined room with long-loved dishes like osso buco and linguine con vongole. Regular participant in Devour Indy and praised by local writers for attentive service and a thoughtful wine list.

Modern Italian with neighborhood energy: crisp arancini, house pastas, and a smart aperitivo program in a stylish space just north of downtown. Featured in Devour Indy lineups and cited by local critics for lively hospitality and balanced plates.

Fountain Square’s stylish Italian from the Ambrosia family’s next generation brings shareable antipasti, handmade pastas, and spritz culture. Covered by local press for its opening and often recommended for pre-show dinners and lively weekend nights.

Mass Ave’s contemporary Italian draws crowds for wood-fired pizzas, playful pastas, and an aperitivo-friendly cocktail list. Highlighted by Indianapolis Monthly’s Best Restaurants coverage and noted by local media for revitalizing a key downtown corner.

Inside The Alexander, Nesso leans coastal Italian with house-made pastas, seafood, and one of Indiana’s broader Italian wine lists. Regularly featured during Devour Indy and cited by local editors for polished service and downtown convenience.

Southside stalwart with family roots reaching back decades, known for hearty vodka sauce, classics like chicken Giovanni, and neighborhood warmth. Frequently recommended by locals and included in citywide dining promotions for its community ties.