4

Sam’s Square Pie

Pizza restaurant · Indy East ·

Sam’s Square Pie

Pizza restaurant · Indy East ·
@postcardnews
22,027 Postcards · 1,950 Cities

Near-eastside pan pizza with a faithful following for caramelized-edge, sauce-forward squares. Featured in Eater’s list of essential Indy restaurants and spotlighted by local TV segments for meaty, memory-lane flavors made in small, craveable batches.

https://www.eater.com/maps/best-restaurants-indianapolis
Best Pizza in Indianapolis (2025)
View this post on Instagram

Information

Detroit-style pizza with fluffy crust, zesty toppings, and beer

detroit style pizza
garlic knots
friendly staff
el jefe
crispy crust
hot honey
amazing pizza
quality ingredients
Google Rating
4.8 (322)
Yelp Rating
4.8
Featured in Eater
Featured in

2829 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46201 Get directions

$10–20

Order delivery
See Menu
Restroom
Popular for dinner
Cozy
Trendy
Family friendly
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by Brian Garrido
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
See full details

4

Information

Detroit-style pizza with fluffy crust, zesty toppings, and beer

detroit style pizza
garlic knots
friendly staff
el jefe
crispy crust
hot honey
amazing pizza
quality ingredients
Google Rating
4.8 (322)
Yelp Rating
4.8
Featured in Eater
Featured in

2829 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46201 Get directions

$10–20

Order delivery
See Menu
Restroom
Popular for dinner
Cozy
Trendy
Family friendly
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by Brian Garrido
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
Sam’s Square Pie by null
See full details

More Places For You

The Med

Mediterranean restaurant · Irvington

Mediterranean fare, tapas, sangria, patio dining, authentic Greek

3 Postcards

Almost Famous

Cocktail bar · Indianapolis

Spanish tapas, espresso martinis, coffee & live music

1 Postcard

Yaso Jamaican Grill

Jamaican restaurant · Southeast

Tender oxtail, smoky jerk chicken, flavorful curries

2 Postcards

Kountry Kitchen

Soul food restaurant · Kingpark

Iconic soul food diner serving catfish, yams & peach cobbler

3 Postcards

Turchetti’s Delicatessen

Meat wholesaler · Fountain Square

Artisan cured meats, brunch, smash burgers, and groceries

1 Postcard

Indy Hostel

Hostel · Mozel Sander Projects

Guest kitchen, bike rentals, BBQ, concerts, near Monon Trail

0 Postcards

Conrad Indianapolis

Hotel · Wholesale District

Luxury hotel with spa, fitness center, indoor pool, art gallery

2 Postcards

Vyne Dental

Software company · Legendary Hills

Claims processing, attachments, and secure communication

1 Postcard

Chatham Tap Butler

Pub · Butler-Tarkington

British-style pub with local & imported beers, pub fare

1 Postcard

The Bristol

Apartment complex · Indianapolis

Seasonal tasting menu with French techniques & New American flavors

7 Postcards