1

Mama Carolla's

Italian restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects ·

Mama Carolla's

Italian restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects ·
@postcardnews
20,018 Postcards · 1,279 Cities

Set inside a 1920s Mediterranean-style villa, this beloved spot turns out generous, comforting plates and romantic patio evenings. Frequently praised by Indianapolis Monthly and often mentioned by local critics for atmosphere as much as the red-sauce favorites.

https://www.indianapolismonthly.com/restaurant-guide/italian-1/mama-carollas-old-italian-restaurant/
Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis (2025)
View this post on Instagram

Information

Upscale Italian in historic villa; garden dining; housemade tiramisu

Placeholder
Placeholder

1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220 Get directions

$20–30

Reserve a table
Order delivery
See Menu
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
See full details

1

Information

Upscale Italian in historic villa; garden dining; housemade tiramisu

Placeholder
Placeholder

1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220 Get directions

$20–30

Reserve a table
Order delivery
See Menu
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
See full details

More Places For You

Stone Soup Inn

Bed & breakfast · Old Northside

Antiques, cozy rooms, free refreshments, and a 19th-century home

0 Postcards

Chispas Discotheque

Night club · Wolfington

Trendy nightclub offering live music and performances

1 Postcard

Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge

Steak house · Southeast

Steaks, seafood, classic cocktails, live jazz, and a swanky supper club vibe

2 Postcards

St. Elmo Steak House

Steak house · Wholesale District

Historic steakhouse known for its fiery shrimp cocktail

7 Postcards

BEAST

Hamburger restaurant · Riverside

Burgers, fries, and amazing Brussels sprouts with rotating specials

3 Postcards

Jack in the Box

Fast food restaurant · Greenwood Place

Crispy tacos, flavorful chicken sandwich, curly fries

2 Postcards

Abyssinia

Ethiopian restaurant · Eagledale

Authentic Ethiopian cuisine with flavorful vegetarian & meat dishes

1 Postcard

Thaitanium

Thai restaurant · Indianapolis

Modern Thai cafe serving classic fare, desserts, beer & cocktails

1 Postcard

BODHI

Cocktail bar · Indianapolis

Upscale Thai destination with craft beers & cocktails

5 Postcards

King Dough

Pizza restaurant · Indianapolis

Brick-oven pies, hot honey, local beers, and outdoor patio

3 Postcards