1

Mama Carolla's

Italian restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects ·

Mama Carolla's

Italian restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects ·
@postcardnews
22,027 Postcards · 1,950 Cities

Set inside a 1920s Mediterranean-style villa, this beloved spot turns out generous, comforting plates and romantic patio evenings. Frequently praised by Indianapolis Monthly and often mentioned by local critics for atmosphere as much as the red-sauce favorites.

https://www.indianapolismonthly.com/restaurant-guide/italian-1/mama-carollas-old-italian-restaurant/
Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis (2025)
View this post on Instagram

Information

Upscale Italian in 1920s villa w/ full bar & garden

romantic atmosphere
beautiful architecture
attentive service
friendly staff
homemade pasta
cozy atmosphere
date night spot
authentic italian
Google Rating
4.7 (2.6K)
Yelp Rating
4.4
Placeholder

1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220 Get directions

$20–30

Reserve a table
Order delivery
See Menu
Usually a wait
Restroom
Popular for dinner
Dinner reservations recommended
Cozy
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
See full details

1

Information

Upscale Italian in 1920s villa w/ full bar & garden

romantic atmosphere
beautiful architecture
attentive service
friendly staff
homemade pasta
cozy atmosphere
date night spot
authentic italian
Google Rating
4.7 (2.6K)
Yelp Rating
4.4
Placeholder

1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220 Get directions

$20–30

Reserve a table
Order delivery
See Menu
Usually a wait
Restroom
Popular for dinner
Dinner reservations recommended
Cozy
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
Mama Carolla's by null
See full details

More Places For You

Burgeezy

Restaurant · Upper Canal

Vegan comfort food, coffee, desserts, and smoothies

3 Postcards

The Med

Mediterranean restaurant · Irvington

Mediterranean fare, tapas, sangria, patio dining, authentic Greek

3 Postcards

Kurt Vonnegut Museum & Library

Museum · Upper Canal

Replicas of office, typewriter, Slaughterhouse-Five exhibit

0 Postcards

Root & Bone - Indianapolis

Southern restaurant (US) · Mozel Sander Projects

Southern comfort food with a chic vibe, creative cocktails

8 Postcards

Taqueria El Cielo

Mexican restaurant · Indianapolis

Michelin-starred Colombian food with theatrical service

1 Postcard

Love Handle

Restaurant · Indianapolis

Creative brunch & lunch with unique meats, decadent desserts, and retro decor

2 Postcards

Corridor

Mediterranean restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects

Mediterranean dining & market with fresh pasta, seasonal dishes

1 Postcard

Bazbeaux

Pizza restaurant · Mass. Ave Arts District

Eclectic pizzas, sandwiches, stromboli, beer, wine, and patio

0 Postcards

R&R Extreme Wings- Keystone

Chicken wings restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects

Hot wings with diverse sauce options, plus fries and drinks

2 Postcards

JW Marriott Indianapolis

Hotel · Canal Walk

Spacious rooms, Italian restaurant, sports bar, and Starbucks

2 Postcards