Mama Carolla's

Italian restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects

1

@postcardnews

Set inside a 1920s Mediterranean-style villa, this beloved spot turns out generous, comforting plates and romantic patio evenings. Frequently praised by Indianapolis Monthly and often mentioned by local critics for atmosphere as much as the red-sauce favorites.

https://www.indianapolismonthly.com/restaurant-guide/italian-1/mama-carollas-old-italian-restaurant/
Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis (2025)
View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Mama Carolla’s (@mamacarollasindy)

1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220 Get directions

mamacarollas.com
@mamacarollasindy

1 Postcard

Reserve
See full details

More Places For You

Ale Emporium

Restaurant · Allisonville

World-famous Hermanaki wings, pizza & sports bar atmosphere

3 Postcards

Iaria's Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant · Fletcher Place

Classic pasta dinners, pizzas, and cannoli served with hospitality

2 Postcards

Smoking Goose Meatery

Meat wholesaler · Indianapolis

Handcrafted meats, salumi, sausages, charcuterie & more

2 Postcards

JW Marriott Indianapolis

Hotel · Canal Walk

Upscale hotel with Italian restaurant, sports bar, and fitness center.

2 Postcards

Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen

Chicken restaurant · Vertland

Louisiana-inspired chain with spicy fried chicken & biscuits

1 Postcard

Wisanggeni Pawon

Indonesian restaurant · Creekwood

Authentic Indonesian dishes like beef rendang and fried rice

1 Postcard

Goose The Market

Butcher shop deli · Kingpark

Gourmet market & butcher with amazing sandwiches, wine, gelato

3 Postcards

La Margarita Fountain Square

Mexican restaurant · Fountain Square

Mexican plates, premium tequilas & craft beer with a lively patio

2 Postcards

Prime 47- Indy's Steakhouse

Steak house · Wholesale District

Steaks, seafood, wine, live piano in monumental setting

2 Postcards

The Med

Mediterranean restaurant · Irvington

Saganaki, gyros, avgolemono soup, Mediterranean flair

2 Postcards