Mama Carolla's shared by @postcardnews on Postcard

1

Mama Carolla's

Italian restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects ·

22,027 Postcards · 1,950 Cities

Set inside a 1920s Mediterranean-style villa, this beloved spot turns out generous, comforting plates and romantic patio evenings. Frequently praised by Indianapolis Monthly and often mentioned by local critics for atmosphere as much as the red-sauce favorites.

https://www.indianapolismonthly.com/restaurant-guide/italian-1/mama-carollas-old-italian-restaurant/

Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis (2025)

View this post on Instagram

Information

Upscale Italian in 1920s villa w/ full bar & garden

charming atmosphere

great service

romantic atmosphere

reservations recommended

delicious food

cozy atmosphere

outdoor seating

friendly staff

1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220 Get directions

$20–30

Reserve a table

Usually a wait

Restroom

Popular for dinner

Dinner reservations recommended

Cozy

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

See full details

1

Information

Upscale Italian in 1920s villa w/ full bar & garden

charming atmosphere

great service

romantic atmosphere

reservations recommended

delicious food

cozy atmosphere

outdoor seating

friendly staff

1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220 Get directions

$20–30

Reserve a table

Usually a wait

Restroom

Popular for dinner

Dinner reservations recommended

Cozy

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

Mama Carolla's by null

See full details

More Places For You

Photo of King Dough

King Dough

Pizza restaurant · Indianapolis

Craft pizzas, pastas, salads & Italian options with patio

3 Postcards

Photo of Chin Brothers Restaurant

Chin Brothers Restaurant

Burmese restaurant · Greenwood Place

Authentic Burmese & SE Asian dishes, tea, and grocery.

3 Postcards

Photo of Almost Famous

Almost Famous

Cocktail bar · Indianapolis

Spanish-leaning brunch, vegan eats, coffee, cocktails & live acts

1 Postcard

Photo of Long's Bakery

Long's Bakery

Bakery · Glendale

Cash-only institution for donuts, danishes, cakes, and cookies

3 Postcards

Photo of Yaso Jamaican Grill

Yaso Jamaican Grill

Jamaican restaurant · Southeast

Jerk chicken, oxtail, curried goat, and plantains served

2 Postcards

Photo of The Bristol

The Bristol

Apartment complex · Indianapolis

Seasonal tasting menu with French techniques & New American flavors

7 Postcards

Photo of Indianapolis Marriott Downtown

Indianapolis Marriott Downtown

Hotel · Wholesale District

Modern hotel with fitness center, casual restaurant, and bars

1 Postcard

Photo of Iozzo's Garden of Italy

Iozzo's Garden of Italy

Italian restaurant · Pogue's Run

Italian eatery serving classics, wine, & lively courtyard dining

1 Postcard

Photo of Milktooth

Milktooth

Restaurant · Fletcher Place

Inventive brunch dishes, creative coffee & cocktails, seasonal menu

10 Postcards

Photo of 8th Day Distillery - Bottle Shop & Cocktail Bar

8th Day Distillery - Bottle Shop & Cocktail Bar

Distillery · Indianapolis

Craft distillery with seasonal cocktails, mocktails, and local spirits

1 Postcard